THE BLOG

Smart Teens Still Lose Marks for This

analysis skills common mistakes critical thinking study habits Mar 01, 2026

High-ability students often assume understanding is enough. It isn’t.

 

Common mark-losing habits

  • Retelling the plot

  • Explaining what a quote says instead of why it’s used

  • Repeating the question in different words

None of these show thinking.

Analysis over retelling

 

The real shift

Marks come from:

  • Interpretation

  • Reasoning

  • Purposeful explanation 

Capability isn’t the issue — strategy is.

Examiner-focused thinking

 

FAQs

Is retelling ever useful in essays?
Only when it directly supports analysis — otherwise it wastes marks.

Why do smart students retell?
They mistake understanding the text for analysing it.

How can this habit be broken?
By learning structured analysis techniques.

We’re Now on YouTube

We’ve officially launched The Classic High School Teacher on YouTube — and we’d love you to join us.

On the channel, you’ll find clear, practical videos for both parents and teens covering:

  • Essay writing

  • Executive function

  • Exam performance

  • Starting when you’re stuck

  • Building real academic confidence

No fluff. No overwhelm. Just structured thinking and practical strategies that actually work.

If you’ve ever thought, “There has to be a clearer way to do this,” this is it.

👉 Come subscribe and follow along

New videos drop weekly.

See you there!

— Francesca
The Classic High School Teacher